Disability Insurance vs Critical Illness Insurance: Disability Insurance For Doctors Explained


Select Dynamic field

Here's a comprehensive overview of disability insurance vs critical illness insurance, to give you a better understanding of the merits and features of both whilst determining which may be best for you

Disability Insurance vs Critical Illness Insurance: Disability Insurance For Doctors Explained

Choosing between disability insurance vs critical illness for doctors

Do You Prefer a Monthly Payment or One-Time Tax-Free Lumpsum?

In the field of medicine, doctors are often exposed to a variety of risks that could potentially impact their ability to continue practicing. As such, insurance policies such as disability insurance and critical illness insurance are essential tools that can provide financial protection in the event of a debilitating illness or injury. This article will delve into the intricacies of these two types of insurance, focusing specifically on disability insurance for doctors in Ontario.

Insurance can often be a complex topic, with various terms and conditions that can be difficult to navigate. This glossary aims to provide a comprehensive understanding of disability and critical illness insurance, breaking down the key differences, benefits, and considerations for doctors. It is important to note that while this glossary focuses on doctors in Ontario, many of the concepts and principles discussed can be applicable to medical professionals in other regions as well.

Understanding Disability Insurance

Disability insurance is a type of coverage that provides income replacement in the event that a policyholder is unable to work due to a disability. For doctors, this can be particularly important, as their profession often requires a high degree of physical and mental capability. A disability, whether caused by illness or injury, can significantly impact a doctor's ability to perform their duties, leading to a potential loss of income.

Understanding disability insurance in Canada

Disability insurance policies typically pay a percentage of the policyholder's income, often between 60% to 80%. The duration of these benefits can vary depending on the policy, with some providing coverage until the policyholder is able to return to work, while others may provide benefits until a specified age, such as 65.

Types of Disability Insurance

There are two main types of disability insurance: short-term and long-term. Short-term disability insurance typically covers disabilities that last for a few weeks to a few months, while long-term disability insurance provides coverage for disabilities that last for several months to years, or even until retirement.

For doctors, long-term disability insurance can be particularly beneficial, as it can provide a steady stream of income in the event of a long-term disability that prevents them from practicing. However, the specific benefits and coverage can vary greatly depending on the policy, so it's important for doctors to carefully review and understand the terms of their disability insurance policy.

Key Features of Disability Insurance

One key feature of disability insurance is the elimination period, which is the length of time a policyholder must be disabled before they can start receiving benefits. This can range from a few days to several months, depending on the policy. Another important feature is the benefit period, which is the length of time the policyholder will receive benefits once they start. This can range from a few years to until the policyholder reaches retirement age.

Additionally, disability insurance policies often include specific definitions of disability. Some policies may consider a policyholder disabled if they are unable to perform the duties of their specific occupation, while others may only provide benefits if the policyholder is unable to perform any occupation. For doctors, it can be beneficial to have a policy that considers them disabled if they are unable to perform their specific medical specialty.

Understanding Critical Illness Insurance

Critical illness insurance is a type of coverage that provides a lump-sum payment if the policyholder is diagnosed with a specified critical illness. This can include conditions such as cancer, heart attack, or stroke. The funds from a critical illness insurance payout can be used in any way the policyholder chooses, whether that's to cover medical expenses, pay for living expenses, or even take a vacation.

Critical illness insurance for Canadians

Unlike disability insurance, which provides income replacement, critical illness insurance provides a one-time payment. This means that the policyholder does not need to be unable to work to receive the payout. However, the policyholder must survive a certain period of time after the diagnosis, often 30 days, in order to receive the payout.

Types of Critical Illness Insurance

There are two main types of critical illness insurance: simplified issue and fully underwritten. Simplified issue policies do not require a medical exam, but they often cover fewer conditions and have lower coverage amounts. Fully underwritten policies require a medical exam and often cover a wider range of conditions and offer higher coverage amounts.

For doctors, fully underwritten policies can often provide more comprehensive coverage. However, the specific benefits and coverage can vary greatly depending on the policy, so it's important for doctors to carefully review and understand the terms of their critical illness insurance policy.

Key Features of Critical Illness Insurance

One key feature of critical illness insurance is the survival period, which is the length of time a policyholder must survive after being diagnosed with a critical illness in order to receive the payout. This can range from a few days to several months, depending on the policy. Another important feature is the covered conditions, which are the specific illnesses or diseases that the policy covers.

Additionally, critical illness insurance policies often include specific definitions of each covered condition. This means that a policyholder must meet the specific definition of a covered condition in order to receive the payout. For example, a policy may specify that a heart attack must result in certain levels of heart damage in order for the policyholder to receive the payout.

Disability Insurance vs Critical Illness Insurance

While both disability insurance and critical illness insurance can provide financial protection in the event of a serious illness or injury, there are key differences between the two. The main difference is in the way benefits are paid out. Disability insurance provides ongoing income replacement if the policyholder is unable to work, while critical illness insurance provides a one-time lump sum payment upon diagnosis of a covered condition.

Another key difference is in the conditions covered. Disability insurance covers any condition that prevents the policyholder from working, while critical illness insurance only covers specific conditions listed in the policy. Additionally, disability insurance typically requires the policyholder to be unable to work in order to receive benefits, while critical illness insurance does not have this requirement.

Choosing Between Disability Insurance and Critical Illness Insurance

When choosing between disability insurance and critical illness insurance, doctors should consider their specific needs and circumstances. For example, a doctor who has a high income and significant financial obligations may benefit more from the income replacement provided by disability insurance. On the other hand, a doctor who has significant savings and wants to protect against the financial impact of a specific critical illness may benefit more from critical illness insurance.

It's also important to consider the cost of each type of insurance. Disability insurance premiums are typically based on the policyholder's income and occupation, while critical illness insurance premiums are typically based on the policyholder's age and health. Therefore, the cost of each type of insurance can vary greatly depending on the individual doctor's circumstances.

Combining Disability Insurance and Critical Illness Insurance

While it's possible to choose between disability insurance and critical illness insurance, many doctors choose to have both types of coverage. This can provide a more comprehensive level of protection, as it covers both the loss of income due to disability and the financial impact of a critical illness.

When combining disability insurance and critical illness insurance, it's important to consider how the benefits from each type of insurance will interact. For example, the payout from a critical illness insurance policy could potentially reduce the benefits received from a disability insurance policy. Therefore, it's important for doctors to carefully review the terms of each policy and consider seeking advice from a financial advisor or insurance professional.

Disability Insurance for Doctors in Ontario

In Ontario, doctors have access to a variety of disability insurance options. These can range from group policies offered through professional associations, to individual policies offered by private insurance companies. The specific benefits and coverage can vary greatly depending on the policy, so it's important for doctors in Ontario to carefully review and understand the terms of their disability insurance policy.

When choosing a disability insurance policy, doctors in Ontario should consider their specific needs and circumstances. For example, a doctor who has a high income and significant financial obligations may benefit more from a policy that provides a high percentage of income replacement. On the other hand, a doctor who has significant savings and wants to protect against the financial impact of a long-term disability may benefit more from a policy that provides benefits until retirement age.

Key Considerations for Doctors in Ontario

When choosing a disability insurance policy, there are several key considerations for doctors in Ontario. One important consideration is the definition of disability. As mentioned earlier, some policies may consider a policyholder disabled if they are unable to perform the duties of their specific occupation, while others may only provide benefits if the policyholder is unable to perform any occupation. For doctors, it can be beneficial to have a policy that considers them disabled if they are unable to perform their specific medical specialty.

Another important consideration is the elimination period and benefit period. Doctors in Ontario should consider how long they can financially sustain themselves without income, and choose an elimination period that aligns with this. Similarly, they should consider how long they would need income replacement in the event of a long-term disability, and choose a benefit period that aligns with this.

Getting Disability Insurance in Ontario

Doctors in Ontario can obtain disability insurance through a variety of sources. These can include professional associations, private insurance companies, and financial advisors. When choosing a source, it's important to consider the reputation and reliability of the provider, as well as the specific benefits and coverage of the policy.

It's also important for doctors in Ontario to regularly review and update their disability insurance policy. This can ensure that the policy continues to meet their needs as their circumstances change, such as increases in income or changes in health status.

Disability Insurance vs Critical Illness Insurance: Conclusion

Disability insurance and critical illness insurance are both important tools that can provide financial protection for doctors in the event of a serious illness or injury. While there are key differences between the two types of insurance, both can play a crucial role in a doctor's financial plan. By understanding the key features and considerations of each type of insurance, doctors can make informed decisions that best meet their needs and circumstances.

Conclusion of disability vs critical illness insurance

For doctors in Ontario, it's particularly important to understand the specifics of disability insurance, as this type of insurance can provide essential income replacement in the event of a disability. By carefully reviewing and understanding the terms of their disability insurance policy, doctors in Ontario can ensure that they have the protection they need to continue their important work in the medical field.

Disability Insurance Advisor Contact 

Resident
  • Resident
  • Fellow
  • Student
  • Attending
  • Salaried Employee
Select Your Specialty
  • Select Your Specialty
  • Allergy
  • Allergy: Immunology
  • Anesthesiology
  • Anesthesiology: Pain Management
  • Anesthesiology: Pediatric
  • Cardiology: Electrophysiology
  • Cardiology: Invasive
  • Cardiology: Invasive-Interventional
  • Cardiology: Non-Invasive
  • Critical Care: Intensivist
  • CRNA
  • Dentistry: General
  • Dentistry: Endodontics
  • Dentistry: Pediatric
  • Dentistry: Prosthodontics
  • Dentistry: Periodontics
  • Dentistry: Orthodontics
  • Dermatology
  • Dermatology: Dermatopathology
  • Dermatology: Mohs Surgery
  • Emergency Medicine
  • Endocrinology/Metabolism
  • Family Medicine (with OB)
  • Family Medicine (without OB)
  • Family Medicine: Ambulatory Only (No Inpatient Work)
  • Family Medicine: Sports Medicine
  • Gastroenterology
  • Gastroenterology: Hepatology
  • Geriatrics
  • Hematology/Oncology
  • Hematology/Oncology: Oncology (Only)
  • Hospice/Palliative Care
  • Hospitalist: Family Medicine
  • Hospitalist: Internal Medicine
  • Hospitalist: IM-Pediatric
  • Hospitalist: OB/GYN
  • Hospitalist: Pediatric
  • Infectious Disease
  • Internal Medicine: General
  • Internal Medicine: Ambulatory Only (No Inpatient Work)
  • Internal Medicine: Pediatric
  • Neonatology
  • Nephrology
  • Neurology
  • Nurse
  • Nurse Practitioner
  • Obstetrics/Gynecology: General
  • OB/GYN: Gynecology (Only)
  • OB/GYN: Gynecological Oncology
  • OB/GYN: Maternal and Fetal Med
  • OB/GYN: Reproductive Endocrinology
  • OB/GYN: Urogynecology
  • Occupational Medicine
  • Ophthalmology
  • Ophthalmology: Corneal & Ref Surgery
  • Ophthalmology: Pediatric
  • Ophthalmology: Retina
  • Orthopedic (Nonsurgical)
  • Orthopedic Surgery: General
  • Orthopedic Surgery: Foot & Ankle
  • Orthopedic Surgery: Hand
  • Orthopedic Surgery: Hip & Joint
  • Orthopedic Surgery: Pediatric
  • Orthopedic Surgery: Spine
  • Orthopedic Surgery: Sports Medicine
  • Orthopedic Surgery: Trauma
  • Otolayrngology
  •  Otorhinolaryngology
  •  Otorhinolaryngology: Pediatric
  •  Pain Management: Nonanesthesia
  •  Pathology: Anatomic & Clinical
  •  Pathology: Anatomic
  •  Pathology: Clinical
  •  Pediatrics: General
  •  Pediatrics: Adolescent Medicine
  •  Pediatrics: Allergy/Immunology
  •  Pediatrics: Cardiology
  •  Pediatrics: Child Development
  •  Pediatrics: Critical Care/Intensivist
  •  Pediatrics: Emergency Medicine
  •  Pediatrics: Endocrinology
  •  Pediatrics: Gastroenterology
  •  Pediatrics: Genetics
  •  Pediatrics: Hematology/Oncology
  •  Pediatrics: Infectious Disease
  •  Pediatrics: Neonatal Medicine
  •  Pediatrics: Nephrology
  •  Pediatrics: Neurology
  •  Pediatrics: Pulmonology
  •  Pediatrics: Radiology
  •  Pediatrics: Urgent Care
  •  Pharmacist
  •  Physician Assistant
  •  Physiatry (Physical Medicine & Rehabilitation)
  •  Physical Therapy
  •  Podiatry: General
  •  Podiatry: Surgery-Foot & Ankle
  •  Psychiatry: General
  •  Psychiatry: Child & Adolescent
  •  Psychiatry: Geriatric
  •  Pulmonary Medicine: General
  •  Pulmonary Medicine: Critical Care
  •  Pulmonary Medicine: General & Critical Care
  •  Radiation Oncology
  •  Radiology: Interventional
  •  Radiology: Diagnostic
  •  Radiology: Neurological
  •  Radiology: Nuclear Medicine
  •  Rheumatology
  •  Sleep Medicine
  •  Surgery: General
  •  Surgery: Bariatric
  •  Surgery: Breast
  •  Surgery: Cardiovascular
  •  Surgery: Cardiovascular-Pediatric
  •  Surgery: Colon & Rectal
  •  Surgery: Neurological
  •  Surgery: Neurological-Pediatric
  •  Surgery: Oncology
  •  Surgery: Oral
  •  Surgery: Pediatric
  •  Surgery: Plastic & Reconstruction
  •  Surgery: Thoracic (Primary)
  •  Surgery: Transplant
  •  Surgery: Trauma
  •  Surgery: Vascular (Primary)
  •  Urgent Care
  •  Urology
  •  Urology - Pediatric
Interested in Life Insurance?
Yes
No
Canadian Citizen
  • Canadian Citizen
  • Permanent Resident
  • Foreign Citizen

Disability Insurance is Complicated

Here are answers to frequently asked questions...

Is there a cost to obtain my disability insurance through you?

No, the only thing you will ever pay is a premium to the insurance company that provides the disability insurance policy for you.

 

Are there disability insurance discounts available for physicians and dentists?

Yes, we have access to various discounts based on your income, your affiliation with a specialty association and other factors. These discounts will be determined and applied during your quote request process

 

How are my disability insurance rates determined?

Rates are based on your age, health history, smoking status, gender and income. The insurance company also compares and makes assessments based on similar individuals with the same profile like age, gender, smoker status, specialty and province of practice. Unlike association rates which are based on the claims of the whole group i.e. your rate is affected by someone who smokes even if you don't smoke, or if you neve claim and other claim multiple times, for example.

 

What is the process of getting a quote and applying?

We simplify the process knowing how busy doctors get and need flexibility. The first step is simply to request your quotes and getting a sense of the cost and coverage available. Next, we compare the policy options and other riders like Own Occupation and discuss what makes sense for you and answer your questions. Lastly, you apply and buy risk-free.

 

If I am currently a resident or fellow, will I/can I increase my benefit amount once my training is completed?

Yes you can increase it and that is our recommendation. Anywhere you do residency in Canada for example, you’re automatically enrolled in a health-benefits plan, which includes disability insurance coverage. As a resident you can purchase a private disability policy under the Medical Student Offer for example. The benefit of this is that you don't have to go through a medical examination to qualify.

The more relevant clause is what's called "Future Income Option" which gives you the option in the future to buy more disability insurance if your income increases, without having to worry about your health having changed just in case. The monthly benefit and premium will depend on your new income, age, and province you’ll be practicing. The process is simple and will not require you to undergo medical underwriting.

 

How long does it take to get my disability insurance policy in place?

In most cases, it can take between 1-3 months from beginning to end. A lot of the time may depend on follow up information required by the insurance company. In our experience 1 month is usually a standard timeframe.

How do I know you have no conflicts of interest in your recommendations?

As an independent insurance broker we have no affiliation with any one insurance company. We know which insurance company is most suited for the type of disability insurance policy that is most conducive for doctors. As a broker we get a finders fee from these insurance companies and they are all the same, without any financial conflict of interest either.

What is underwriting and when does it start?

Underwriting is where the insurance company verifies your information that you submitted on the application your complete with us and gathers additional details such as health history , travel, and personal history to determine the best rate possible.


Tags


You may also like

Do you know where you stand with your financial plan? Take a 3-min quiz.